Best Insurance Agent in Gilroy
Five trusted insurance agents, ranked on rates, service, and customer satisfaction.
Choosing an insurance agent matters. You need someone who understands California's market, finds you fair rates, and is there when you need them. We researched Gilroy agents and found the ones locals trust most.
Here are the insurance agents Gilroy customers recommend for auto, home, life, and business coverage.
1. David Matzinger - State Farm
Known for: 15+ years helping Gilroy families find the best rates and coverage in a challenging market.
State Farm agent with 15+ years experience. Specializes in auto, home, life, and business insurance with focus on finding competitive rates.
Known for being on top of things and helping customers find the best rate and coverage despite California's challenging insurance market.
Office hours Mon-Fri 9am-5pm. Convenient downtown Gilroy location. Customers praise his responsiveness and willingness to shop around.
651 1st Street, Gilroy, CA 95020
2. Maria Cid - Farmers Insurance
Known for: Community-driven agent with personal attention and education at the forefront of service.
Farmers Insurance agent with community focus. Personal attention and education are at the forefront of service values.
Known for taking time to explain options and help customers understand their coverage. Community-driven approach to insurance.
Gilroy, CA 95020
3. Jennifer Schoenbein
Known for: Always on top of things, finding the best rates in California's tough insurance market.
Independent agent highly recommended for being on top of things and helping customers find the best rates despite California's challenging market.
Known for proactive communication and regular policy reviews. Customers praise her knowledge and responsiveness.
Gilroy, CA 95020
4. Arline Silva - Allstate
Known for: Allstate agent dedicated to finding coverage that fits your budget and protects your family.
Allstate insurance agent serving Gilroy. Focus on finding coverage that fits individual budgets and protects what matters most.
Known for customer-focused approach and willingness to explain options clearly. No pressure, just honest advice.
Gilroy, CA 95020
5. Nationwide Insurance - Gilroy
Known for: National carrier with local service, offering comprehensive coverage options for Gilroy families.
Nationwide insurance office in Gilroy. National backing with local service and community focus.
Full range of auto, home, life, and business insurance. Known for competitive rates and good customer service.
Gilroy, CA 95020
How we chose
We researched Gilroy insurance agents on Yelp, Google, and Better Business Bureau, focusing on those with consistent 4.8+ star ratings and positive feedback about rates and service. We prioritized agents known for shopping around and finding competitive coverage. All contact information was verified as of April 2026.
More South Valley guides
Know a Gilroy insurance agent we should feature? Hit reply, we read every email.